The Moral Economy

Why Good Incentives Are No Substitute For Good Citizens

Book Cover: The Moral Economy

This book by Samuel Bowles explores the theory that incentives might backfire if they foster the very self-interest that they were designed to harness. He gives the example of a child care centre which adopted a policy of fining parents if they were late in picking up their children with the result that late pickups increased as parents felt it was morally acceptable provided they paid the fine. The rule was subsequently reversed but this group continued to be late in picking up their children compared to a control group which did not have any change in policy.

Putting a price on every human activity erodes certain moral and civic goods worth caring about.

Having noticed a suspicious bunching of sick call-ins on Mondays and Friday's the Boston fire Commissioner ended the fire department policy of unlimited paid sick days. Instead, he imposed a limit of 15 sick days and if fireman exceeded that limit they would have their pay docked. The number of fireman calling in sick on Christmas and New Years Day increased tenfold as a result. The Fire Commissioner retaliated by cancelling the fireman's holiday bonus cheques. The firemen were unimpressed and in the next year, they claimed 13431 sick days up from 6432 a year earlier. Many firemen apparently insulted by the new system abused it or abandon their previous ethic of serving the public even when injured or not feeling well.

Why do policies and business practices that ignore the moral and generous side of human nature often fail? Should the idea of economic man-the amoral and self-interested Homo economicus-determine how we expect people to respond to monetary rewards, punishments, and other incentives? Samuel Bowles answers with a resounding "no." Policies that follow from this paradigm, he shows, may "crowd out" ethical and generous motives and thus backfire. But incentives per se are not really the culprit. Bowles shows that crowding out occurs when the message conveyed by fines and rewards is that self-interest is expected, that the employer thinks the workforce is lazy, or that the citizen cannot otherwise be trusted to contribute to the public good. Using historical and recent case studies as well as behavioral experiments, Bowles shows how well-designed incentives can crowd in the civic motives on which good governance depends.

Please follow and like us:


Testimonials

Only just found this podcast. LOVE IT

Really great to see some honest conversation, that doesn’t seem concerned with making the truth more palatable for the fair of heart. I think we really need a lot more of this.

Kena161975

Great listen

Fantastic podcast and gets better every episode. BUT if you can’t handle the truth about the dismal state of Australian politics give this one a miss.

The Happy Dog

Look forward to this podcast every week

This is an entertaining and intelligent discussion of politics, religion, education and other important issues in Australia. If you’re not interested in politics or if you’re confused by it then you need to listen to these guys. They remove the mystery and put forward an analysis of the issues that will entertain and inform you.

Saroq

Ep 81, one of the best and most enjoyable

Wel done Trevor and Hugh, one of the best Eps to date. Professional delivery by both.

AussieKomet

Episode 68 right on the mark

This episode was just the right length, but more importantly, was a little more measured in addressing the topics. I admire the Iron Fist in the way he can craft rational statements about appalling behaviour in the topics discussed, and I found the 12th Man to be a good balance to the Iron Fist. I wish the Velvet Glove wouldn’t giggle at important topics or when religious thinking is described – we already find them ridiculous, but laughing every time is a bit much after hours of listening to episodes. This is a fun but semi-serious podcast that everyone should listen to, and I thank them for making the time to produce it.

Townie49

Keep it going…

A refreshing podcast. Rational discussion on topics many won’t tackle honestly. I don’t agree with everything you say but I love the way your subject matter is explored and sometimes debated. Great work guys.

nedd_

Making baby Jesus cry

Don’t listen to these baby eating heathens, God will kill an angel for every episode that you listen to.

Rhhhgdtgvv

Presenting the Inconvenient Truth

These guys are at the forefront of challenging religious privilege. If you want to be up-to-date on all the wacky goings-on by the religion pushers in this world and their attempts successful or otherwise to influence the political and social spheres of our lives then this is your podcast. We need more of this advocacy for a secular world view. Be like me or Bill and don’t miss an episode.

Amchila

Christmas Special

All podcasts are great but the christmas special takes the cake. Excellent show guys.

Dvork123

Donations

Enjoy this Podcast? Please spread the word :)